Butterton Hotels  | Miles  | Rating | Price |
| The Manifold Inn | 2.75 |  | From £36.67 |
| Stanshope Hall | 3.2 | | From £77.50 |
| YHA Hartington Hall | 4.23 | | From £86.00 |
| YHA Ilam Hall | 4.6 | | From £20.65 |
| The Izaak Walton Hotel | 5.12 |  | From £70.00 |
| Whiston Hall | 5.83 | | From £97.50 |
| The Jug and Glass Inn | 5.91 | From £45.00 | |
| Dog and Partridge Country Inn | 5.96 |  | From £65.00 |
